Classic Car Market Overview - May 2002

By Simon Kidston, President of Bonhams Europe
 

An auction packed month of May saw Bonhams hold their first sale in the Boston area, setting up shop at the Brookline Transport Museum where gusting winds blew down the auction marquee the night before the sale! Despite the weather the event was well attended and packed with 'discoveries' fresh from long-term museum display, including a delightfully tired Bugatti Type 49 Coupe, which looked suspiciously like a Bristol 400 from the rear! It flew past its estimate to sell for $93,800.

Generally speaking, unrestored gems of this ilk did very well, but it was also reassuring at last to see a Ferrari Boxer finding an appreciative home, this time a 1974 example landed for $78,400.


Highlight of the sale was undoubtedly the little Osca MT4 which drew a deserving bid of $266,500. The same car would probably have sold for half this amount just five years ago - usability, aesthetics and pedigree are the key words today, and the Osca had them all.

Much anticipation was reserved for the 'no reserve' sell-off of the bankrupt Prost F1 team's cars which came under Hervé Poulain's hammer on 6th May at the Palais des Congres in Paris. Despite development costs which would make even a telecoms billionaire think twice, F1 cars of the modern era have traditionally been hard to sell for less than pennies in the pound of their original value.
There are virtually no events for them, you need a team of engineers with electronics degrees just to start the engine, and most collectors well-heeled enough to afford one cannot reconcile sitting in it with the side effects of gourmet cuisine.

Nonetheless media and public interest in the sad fate of the last 100% French owned F1 team was great, and the ex-Alesi 2000 car achieved a resounding Euros 240,000, closely followed by Trulli's 1997 mount at Euros 210,000. There were some bargains too however, namely 1996 and 1997 cars, both without engines, which sold respectively for Euros 30,000 and Euros 29,000.

The most remarkable result of the sale, and it could only happen in France, was the Euros 36,000 paid for a 4-wheel drive Citroen 2CV in immaculately restored condition, almost twice the price of the last one sold by Poulain three years ago.

The next major auction fixture took place at Aston Martin's venerable Newport Pagnell factory on 11th May, where Bonhams held their annual sale devoted to the renowned British marque. The frenzy surrounding Aston Automobilia may have died down (at Bonhams' first A-M sale an enamel sign made £15,000) but the factory was absolutely packed with bidders who knew what they wanted.

Undoubted highlight was the limited edition SWB Vantage Volante of which just eight were built in 2000 for special clients. This supercharged beast was knocked down for even more than it cost its first owner, at just over a quarter of a million GB£.

Non-Sale Cars from the Leyba Collection

All the cars from the Robert Leyba collection (eight in total) were sold and even the child's Virage Volante Junior doubled its estimate at £12,500, a lot of pocket money for most but perhaps not for the offspring of an Aston owner.


'Fireworks were expected for the head-to-head sales of Coys and Bonhams in glamorous Monte Carlo during the weekend of the Grand Prix Historique, but in the event buyers were prudent and, while some cars set new price levels, others seemed good value or did not sell.
Coys sale on the Friday evening drew the usual trade biased crowd but seemed subdued. Although it is very difficult to verify their results (many cars were run up to over the bottom estimate and then declared as not sold, whilst others were declared as sold and subsequently turned out not to be), it appears from a quick calculation that approximately 40% of the cars actually changed hands. Perhaps buyers were put off by the lack of information in the catalogue or the large number of estimates marked "Refer Department".

In the event the most expensive car sold was the ex-Works Austin Healey for which its owner of 30 years will be doubtlessly be pleased to get Euros 171,750 - not a bad investment.

The Bugatti Type 51 which had originally been entered for this sale was, not surprisingly, withdrawn (see my February article) and a pair of 6 cylinder Alfa Romeos of questionable provenance also failed to sell.

The Ferrari SWB trumpeted in early advertising turned out to be a replica (but sold anyway) and the Alfa Romeo 8C which has done the rounds was knocked down as sold, but turns out not to have been. No official results have yet been published.