Classic Car Market Overview - March 2002

By Simon Kidston, President of Bonhams Europe
 

March is always a busy month in the classic car auction world with the season really getting under way after a usually quiet winter in Europe. First to kick off were London dealers Coys of Kensington with a fixture at their now traditional venue, the Design Centre in Islington. This was a mixed sale and the success rate was not spectacular, with a number of cars finding homes only after the auction. Amongst these was the 1967 Earls Court Motor Show Iso Grifo, originally billed as the ex-John Lennon car but it turns out he was only photographed sitting in it on the Motor Show stand! This Italo-American beauty seemed good value at £23,000.

No less than three 1973 Porsche Carrera RSs were offered at Coys, and despite the renewed popularity of this model only one found a buyer at a lowly £26,000. From the same year of production, a beautiful 19,500 mile Ferrari 365 Boxer struggled to £26,500 and was not sold. From the heady late 1980s when Boxers changed hands for over £200,000, they have come a long way: surely one of the supercar bargains of today. Overall, this was neither one of Coys' most memorable sales nor a disaster.

On the same day Poulain le Fur held one of their 'popular classic' sales in Paris, mixing second hand modern luxury models with mid-level classics. These auctions represent a relatively new initiative and complement Poulain's larger prestige sales well. One of the minor highlights of this event was the Mercedes-Benz 280SE 3.5 litre coupé first owned by French actor Lino Ventura which was hammered down for a resounding Euros 25,000 (estimate Euros 15,000 - 22,000).

Another relatively mundane car with a famous first owner was a 2001 Mercedes-Benz S320 owned by the late Princess Soraya (the Shah of Iran's daughter who tragically died last year), which also exceeded its pre-sale estimate to sell for Euros 55,000, the highest price of the day.

First of the 'big' sales in March was RM at Amelia Island in Florida. RM produced a thick catalogue of superb variety mixing 1930s American grand classics, 1950s 'yank tanks', the usual European sports models and one or two star lots such as the ex-Terry Cohn Alfa Romeo Monza which the company had underwritten in order to secure its sale. A number of cars were also included from actor Nicolas Cage's stable. If the quality of the catalogue presentation was not universally up to RM's normal standards, the results did not disappoint.

The Alfa Romeo Monza was good value, knocked down well below estimate for a premium inclusive $2,530,000 to a well-known East Coast collector of Italian cars, whilst Nicolas Cage's 1938 Bugatti Type 57 Atalante was spot on the money at its lower estimate of $451,000. His whacky Bugatti Type 101, basically a warmed up Type 57 with post-war bodywork, did not sell.

The American owned Ferrari 375 MM, which had been rebodied by Scaglietti early in its life and was arguably not as attractive as a Pinin Farina bodied car, did well to achieve $1,925,000.

Cage's Jaguar D-Type found a new owner for $935,000 (after the auction we believe), which seems o be the level for an average D-Type these days. It's funny to note how C-Types have risen so much while D-Types have stood still, making them good value today in my opinion.

RM also did well to despatch a 1938 Mercedes-Benz 540K for $ 1.0 million, the market norm for a really superb Cabriolet 'A' right now.

American classics of the 1930s and 1950s do not appear often at auction in Europe and RM usually manage to find a good selection for each of their major sales. At Amelia Island there was something for everybody, from a 1932 Duesenburg Model 'J', surely the epitome of Great Gatsby flamboyance, sold at $671,000, through to a brand new 2002 Cadillac Eldorado ESC, somewhat out of place but nonetheless finding a buyer for $45,000.