Classic Car Market Overview - May/ June 2003

By Simon Kidston, President of Bonhams Europe
 

Leaving aside minor sales, the last and most important May fixture was Bonhams Les Grandes Marques down in Monaco, where top slot went to the delivery mileage CLK Mercedes-Benz road car at EUR733,000, closely followed by a Porsche 911 GT1 road car at EUR580,000, showing that even these notoriously fashion sensitive supercars will attract buyers if the price is right. Other market indicators were the EUR362,000 paid for the beautifully restored Ferrari 275GTB/4 (no, they are not all worth that now) or the EUR120,000 which secured probably the finest Maserati 3500 GT Spider seen in recent years (yes, an equivalent car should now fetch an equivalent amount). Although the sale rate of around 60% was not remarkable, almost all the expensive lots sold, making this Bonhams' highest value Monaco sale since May 2000, also the peak of the stock market and perhaps a telling indicator.



June's major sales began with Christie's at the Rockefeller Center in New York, where the scruffy ex-Frank Sinatra Miura disappointed at $150,500 (less than his Jaguar XJS made at Pebble Beach four years ago) whilst a quirky Abarth 1500 Coupé achieved a whopping $293,500, again confirming the interest in genuine barn discoveries. It is surprising that despite this sale's fantastic location not more New York dollars found their way into the cars on offer, but I hope Christie's persevere with this sale as it is a brilliant concept with great potential.

Rockefeller Center, New York

 

On 16th June Christie's and Artcurial (Poulain) went head to head in London and Paris respectively. Highlight of Christie's sale was a roadgoing McLaren F1 presented in a vivid blue which perhaps limited its appeal. An all-inclusive price of £593,750 at last shows what one of these cars in mint condition is really worth today.
Another highlight was the pretty Bugatti Type 37 which seemed spot-on at £192,800, but otherwise the Bugatti Type 57 Drophead Coupé, Cooper Climax Type 45, MG Magnette N-Type, Alfa Romeo179/C Formula 1 car, Rolls-Royce Silver Ghost and Rolls-Royce Silver Cloud 1 Drophead all failed to sell.


Later that afternoon Artcurial offered the famous Ferrari 330GTC Speciale owned until her death last year by Princess Lilian de Réthy. Extensively publicised and offered directly from the Princess's estate, every market pundit had an opinion on this car's value. Some said EUR200,000, others as much as EUR300,000. Applause broke out when the hammer fell at EUR520,000, but this was nothing compared to the surprise and awe when it emerged that Artcurial had accepted the car with an even higher reserve price and it was actually unsold! This really killed the sale and one has to question the judgement of the firm's 'experts' in accepting such an overpriced car, particularly when estate disposals are usually keenly priced. Too much Piat d'Or?

Other than the 'Jaguar Legend' on 21st June, for which Coys has still not created the results, that was it for June on the international scene.

In the next report we will look at Bohams Goodwood Festival of Speed sale, H&H's auction on 23rd July in Buxton and Bonhams Summer Vintage sale at Lords, before the major extravaganza in Pebble Beach in mid-August which sees Bonhams, RM and Christie's battling it out.

Overall the market seems to be waking up but vendors would do well not to get ahead of themselves. There is money out there for the right car in the right condition, with the right history and at the right price … but not at any price. Buyers too should accept that if they like the car, and can afford it, they should step up.

Back to the first page